43. Promoting the Wrong Leaders Will Kill Your Company’s Growth

Episode 43: Promoting the Wrong Leaders Will Kill Your Company’s Growth

Episode 6 in the series, Scaling Growth

At 100 people, the pressure to promote more managers is real. But promoting your best doer, rewarding tenure, or overloading the people you already have doesn’t create leadership — it creates dysfunction.

In this episode, James unpacks why leadership quality, not just quantity, is the next threshold for scaling. He shares how leaders who aren’t prepared end up in over their heads, why loyalty and tenure don’t automatically make someone a leader, and how overextended managers drift into task management instead of leading people.

This episode is for founders who are staring at their org chart, realizing some of the people in those leadership boxes were never ready — and that the cost of ignoring it is culture erosion, missed expectations, and creeping politics.

• Why promoting skill over readiness puts people in over their heads
• How loyalty and tenure don’t automatically translate to building other leaders
• The hidden cost of overloading managers until they default to managing tasks
• The truth: leaders must be ready before Day 1 — not developed in crisis

Reflection Questions

• Who in your company is in over their head because they were promoted for skill, not leadership readiness?
• Where are your managers managing tasks but failing to lead people?
• What’s one action you can take this quarter to prepare leaders before you hand them a title?

Links and Resources

The Next Question Guide → NextQuestionGuide.com

LinkedIn → linkedin.com/in/jamesmayhew

Website → JamesMayhew.com